So apparently the Government of Canada wants its good citizens to save money. Any good citizen needs an incentive and the TFSA is it. however, one must wonder why the government would voluntarily forgo some revenue by not taxing the money earned within TFSAs. My dear amigos the answer is a preemptive strike on the credit crunch. Here in Canada the crunch is not evident just yet, but reading any financial paper in the USA it is plain obvious. Some journals are comparing the current scenario with bank runs of the 30’s era. If the government foresees that, the TFSE is a genius solution.
If only 10 million people use it, that’s $50 billion injection into the banking system. Banks will have capital to lend and the economy should chug along nicely. I applaud. This is a clever way to fight any credit crunch. (Although i do realize that $50 billion on a grand scale is not a lot, but it is a start.) Furthermore, I applaud the government for creating a way to earn income tax free. So go ahead deposit your hard earned dollars into the TFSA and collect the rewards.
As an aside in most cases and at least in the first few years of the TFSA it would only makes sense to save after maxing out the RRSP deduction limit. The money put into the TFSA is not tax deductible, while RRSP contributions are. So essentially each all deposits to TFSA are after tax dollars and therefore worth a bit less than RRSP dollars. However, this difference can be made up with the tax free benefit of the income created with the TFSA. Clever investing people - that’s what I’m talking about.
However, when a government gives incentives one should look if any one else or any other groups are benefiting.